Specifically the role of Alex Kamal - as in, the character moments and scenes specific to him, not ones that can just as easily be reassigned to another character and maintain all the meaning of that scene.Īnd it is a shame because I can not say the same for Holden, Amos, Naomi or (maybe to a lesser extent, but still true) Bobbie. I love the character, but if we consider that they are not replacing him in Season 5 in any way (because, of course they can't,) then we have to consider his role in the story going forwards after season 5. That being said, I do not think the show, if faithfully adapted, would lose much from replacing Alex Kamal, despite being a wonderful character (because he is.) His role can be filled by any other character without any real loss to the story. It is really difficult to discuss this in any meaningful (to the future of the show as an adaptation of the books, I mean) way if there are absolutely no spoilers in this thread. But in the end, we’re still getting the same epic, and it’s still being told by “Homer”.Īnd that story is about humanity, not any particular pilot. The Expanse is like the Trojan War every telling is slightly different, different aspects get emphasized. But in the end, it will be the same epic told by the same people.
#Alex expanse series#
The book series will differ in noticeable ways from the TV series. Especially given that what “was” is coming to an end. My counsel: embrace the dynamic change that is life. Corey than try to hot-swap some new actor in like Darren on “Bewitched” just so I can get my “original James S.A. I would rather have a new ending by James S.A. No, better to write Kamal out of the story with input from James S.A. You can recast Arjun Avasarala because he’s a minor character.
And a he will get shat upon for his efforts. It will NEVER work, the chemistry between the actors MAYBE will gel in time for the last episode, and everyone will complain about how weird it is the whole time.īut whomever the poor soul who takes on that job will never be thanked for it. No, given that Ty and Daniel are in the writers room, I would rather have them write a new ending to the tv series.Īcting like “This is totally the old Alex” would be an exercise in futility. People expect that somehow to turn out positively? and you wanna hand that over to some other actor in the last season to wrap it up neatly? You’re taking 5-seasons of character interactions, chemistry, and personification. Recasting a major character for the final season is a horrible idea.
As always, read and follow the spoiler flair and rules for any thread you post in. If you haven't read the books, browse this thread at your own risk.Ĭomments that are primarily about Alex, the character, or that mention Cas Anvar's removal as part of a larger thought, are allowed under our rules, but comments that are primarily about Anvar's investigation and removal, or discuss the details of the situation, need to be made in the designated thread.ĭiscussion of Alex, the character, is of course allowed in any thread. All spoilers from the TV show through Season 4 are welcome, but you must tag book events that haven't occurred yet or any plot points from Season 5 as spoilers.Īlex's Future, An All-Spoilers Thread: For discussing the future of the character of Alex Kamal, especially for those who have read all the books and would like to speculate freely about how his character arc may or may not change.
The Future of The Expanse Without Cas Anvar: For discussing how the show may be different with this significant casting change, including recasting ideas. They were created to help collect similar, ongoing discussions together: We also recommend these two threads related specifically to the future of the show without Anvar, and Alex's future as a character.
This thread contains distressing descriptions of sexual assault, harassment, and intimidating behavior, including people under 18 and those vulnerable due to mental health concerns, and mention of suicide attempts. In order to keep disturbing real-world content from dominating unrelated threads, this is the only thread where discussion of the details of the allegations or investigation is allowed, please follow its rules very carefully. This thread is for learning about the situation, discussing the actions Anvar has been accused of, and processing your emotions around his removal. The authors have stated that the decision to end the show after Season 6 had nothing to do with this situation. Information: Cas Anvar will not be returning to The Expanse for Season 6 after an independent legal team's investigation into sexual harassment and assault allegations made by 40+ people, including coworkers.
0 kommentar(er)
